Amanda Marshalls in her
musical influences
Bluesy singer samples Joni Mitchell,
The Staple Singers
By ERROL NAZARETH -- Toronto Sun
TORONTO - Joni Mitchell's been busy.
She was at Seal's concert at the Molson
Amphitheatre Sunday night and she popped up at
Amanda Marshall's sold-out show at Massey Hall
last night.
Truth be told, the venerated songwriter was at
Massey in spirit and song.
Marshall concluded Last Exit by seguing into
Mitchell's Yellow Taxi, singing the chorus -- "Don't
it always seem to go that you don't know what
you've lost 'til it's gone? -- that was brilliantly
sampled by Janet Jackson on her Velvet Rope disc
last year.
Marshall's penchant for mixing and matching songs
-- she dropped Michael Jackson's Man In The
Mirror and Jimi Hendrix's Castles Made Of Sand
into the mix at her '97 show at the Amphitheatre --
is still alive. Sly & The Family Stone showed up
during Right Here, and The Staple Singers slipped
into her hit, Birmingham.
Then there was the cute intro to Shades Of Grey.
Accompanied by her acoustic guitarist, Marshall
recited the Mother Goose poem -- "Monday's
child is fair of face, Tuesday's child is full of grace"
-- before her five-man band launched into a song
which articulates the thoughts of a child of an
interracial marriage.
The song, off her second album, Tuesday's Child,
contains these lines: "You can't change a stubborn
mind, you can't see the world if you eyes are blind,
what does it matter anyway? In our darkest hour
we're all shades of grey."
"Dont' give a damn what they say," she raged
toward the end of the song. "We're all just shades
of grey."
For Marshall's fans, her return to a local stage was
nothing less than triumphant. And the diminutive
singer was clearly hyped -- imagine that! -- to be
performing here.
"It's always a thrill to play your hometown," she
said, before relating some of her most memorable
musical moments -- seeing The Pointer Sisters and
Melissa Etheridge -- at Massey Hall since she was
nine years old.
The sold-out crowd got what they paid for: A
non-stop parade of formulaic pop-rock songs from
Marshall's two albums, all delivered in her big,
bluesy voice.
But you gotta wonder about her lyrics. Consider
these samples -- bland, cliched and tired at worst
-- and the cold reception Tuesday's Child has
received from critics makes sense:
"Somewhere there's a river looking for a stream,
somewhere there's a dreamer looking for a dream"
(from Believe In You); "I don't know what I was
thinking 'til I was thinking of you, I don't know what
I was doing when there was nothing to do" (from If
I Didn't Have You); or "What am I looking for that
just isn't there? I need to feel you need me like a
river needs an ocean" (from Why Don't You Love
Me).
As a friend, who's a walking musical encyclopedia,
said to me, "As a songwriter, she's a great singer."
Whole lot of respect
Marshall shows off Girl Next Door
Power
By IAN NATHANSON
Ottawa Sun
OTTAWA -- All Amanda Marshall asked for
was a little respect.
From roughly 9,000 last night at the Civic Centre,
she got a whole lot in return.
Ranking somewhere in between Sheryl Crow and
Janis Joplin, the Toronto singer was in fine voice
during the second stop on her cross-country tour
backing her sophomore album, Tuesday's Child.
Whether she was crooning a ballad like Beautiful
Goodbye or the Stones-esque Best of Me, both
from the new CD, Marshall flawlessly worked her
magical voice, never quavering from the moment
she set foot on stage until the show's end.
If Girl Power is still alive and well, then Marshall,
25, has probably redefined her role in it -- call it
Girl Next Door Power.
Safety net
She bookended Shades of Grey, her ode to her
parents' interracial marriage, with a familiar nursery
rhyme -- "Monday's child is fair of face, Tuesday's
child is full of grace ..." while middle-aged couples
felt a strong safety net listening to Marshall's words
and music with their children within eye's reach.
And in case anyone missed the point, a
baby-faced photo of Marshall flashed on the
backdrop.
That safety net, however, tends to make for songs
with little substance. Most of Marshall's material
sticks to a well-rehearsed formulaic approach that
lacks any emotion unless she flashes her trademark
big hair flying, arms flailing, stage pacing and
backward bends to signal an oncoming diva belt.
If not for the exposure of TV (show opener
Believe In You appeared on the series Touched By
An Angel) and radio (current single Love Lift Me,
Dark Horse and her signature Let It Rain from her
eponymous debut), hummable tunes would be few
and far between.
Ovations
That didn't seem to matter to the crowd, who
clapped along, applauding loudly after every song,
even louder when she filled in refrains with some
classic gems: Birmingham had The Jeffersons
theme, Joni Mitchell's Big Yellow Taxi capped Last
Exit to Eden and Right Here All Along threw in Sly
and the Family Stone's Thank You (Falletin Me Be
Mice Elf Again). There were even a few standing
ovations to boot.
Credit her five-piece band for keeping the
proceedings running smoothly and allowing
Marshall to have a bit of fun onstage.
That's how she commands R-E-S-P-E-C-T.
Saturday, May 17, 1997
Great voice in search of material
Middle-of-the-road rock
By PAUL CANTIN
Ottawa Sun
What a difference six years make.
Last night, Amanda Marshall played before a sold-out crowd at
the NAC -- the same venue that saw her make her touring
debut as an acoustic opening act for the Jeff Healey Band
around 1991.
Now a platinum artist around the world, and a name dropped
by the likes of Elton John, Marshall has rightly succeeded by
virtue of a singing style that has to be experienced to be
believed. Put it this way: Her voice is as big as her hair.
Marshall was bright and energetic, showing none of the fatigue
one might expect after two years of touring. And truly, even
after a show that built from one frantic climax to another without
pause, Marshall seemed fresh and ready to roar at the end of
the set. Late in the evening, her vocal onslaught at the end of
Beautiful Goodbye was so intense and so straining, you couldn't
help but wonder if Mandy wasn't risking physical injury. There's
a vibrancy and a soulfulness here that her recorded output
barely hints at.
With only one album under her belt, Marshall had a narrow
pool of songs to draw from, but stretched them out in interesting
ways. Her anthemic Let It Rain was prefixed by a version of
Ann Peebles' Hi Records hit, I Can't Stand The Rain. Sitting On
Top Of The World was given an acoustic prelude that was so
charming and understated, the bombastic rock version that
followed couldn't help but seem like a letdown.
And there's part of the problem. In almost every case, the
songs rarely are worthy of the singer. Marshall exhibits a
weakness for middle-of-the-road rock that is only partially
remedied by the grit of her live performance.
When she does latch onto a worthy song -- her cover of Jimi
Hendrix's sublime Castles Made Of Sand, for example -- the
effect is mesmerizing. For now, Marshall remains a fine
performer, with a great voice, in search of great songs.
Opening act Chantal Kreviazuk has no such worries. The young
Winnipegger is blessed with a real talent for composing
soul-baring songs, as she demonstrated on her fine debut LP,
Under These Rocks And Stones.
The real testament to the power of that material, though, came
last night.
Armed with nothing more than a grand piano and her own
sweet voice, Kreviazuk conveyed the sly humor of God Made
Me, the elegantly wasted feel of the Stones' Wild Horses, the
bitterness of Surrounded, and the desperate yearning of her best
song, Wayne.
Like everything else about her too-short set, what lingered was
Kreviazuk's sincerity and passion.
|
||